Why YouTube Video Ads Will Ultimately Fail

Google announced what everyone expected with the addition of video advertisements to YouTube appropriately called InVideo ads earlier this week. The blogosphere has mixed results about the new feature; publishers are eager to make money off of their video offerings and users want a clean, uninterrupted experience.

Fortunately YouTube has decided against pre or post-roll ads citing evidence that viewers just don’t respond. Instead, as the name implies, the ads pop up in-video and only take up the bottom 20% of the player screen. Clicking on the ad will pause the video and open another mini video player inside the one you are watching. Ad metrics are based on the percentage of the ad you get through and if you should leave within the first 15 seconds that doesn’t count as an impression.

YouTube InVideo Ad

Many think video ads will be another big business for Google but video ads are a far different beast compared to text ads. For one, InVideo ads are only shown on the content of trusted partners for obvious legal reasons. Unlike text ads that require no screening process, video owners must have all of the legal clearances to engage in commercial activity. This bottleneck greatly reduces the potential pool of advertisers unlike the ubiquity and ease of AdSense.

Second, in order to prevent “saturation” or dampening the user experience, video ads will have to be deliberately limited. Text ad units are splattered across the web on millions of blogs taking advantage of the Long Tail of niche content. While this means higher costs per click and per thousand impressions the amount of ad inventory is inherently limited.

Finally, ads that pop up in the middle of video, even if for a brief 10 seconds, are distracting. Text ads are successful because they blend in with the content; obvious to the reader when they need them and not a distraction when they are uninterested. Watching video is a concentrative task. Anything that intrudes on the message, stealing the users attention, takes them away from the story and lowers the experience. Think about how annoying it is at a public theater when someone is talking next to you or a cell phone goes off. TBS has been running ads like YouTube’s in the middle of shows like Everybody Loves Raymond however Youtube has a leg up by giving the viewer the freedom to close the ad display right away. See an InVideo ad in action.

Ads in the middle of YouTube videos may be all the buzz now but I feel those enthusiastic of the new feature will eventually grow tired of it like the rest of us. YouTube user fardousha sums it up best with the following comment…

If ads invade youtube, i will desert it.
What attracted me in the first place is ads free quality time. Long story short, it ain’t a good idea.

There is already a Firefox extension called TubeStop to stop YouTube ads from even showing up, protecting the users patience as they take in all that YouTube has to offer. There is only a certain amount of aggravation one can take in regards to advertising and InVideo ads certainly cross that threshold. This is why the YouTube ad experiment will ultimately be a failure.

6 Responses to “ Why YouTube Video Ads Will Ultimately Fail ”

  1. I like what some of the network stations are doing with their online video, giving you 1 or 2 adds by a selected company during the commercial break. Of course this isn’t feasible with youtube and user submitted, non-breaking videos. I have seen an ad like this on another site before youtube, although I forget where. It wasn’t too bad, although at one point the ad that popped up, was over the subtitled/subtext, which is when I really ‘noticed’ the ad.

    Perhaps they should try to bypass this, and just randomly insert logos on people’s clothing, or food products in the video.. lol

    Or maybe contact each person, and force them to use logos in their videos. That should work. ;-)

    Reply

  2. [...] have previously discussed how the current InVideo ads on YouTube will ultimately fail. What can Google do to turn the most popular video distribution hub on the net into a money maker [...]

  3. Can you explain why video aggregators exist and how Google allows it? I have had some of my videos copied (stolen) from youtube and placed on theuniversitytube.com and reposted as that thief’s own video. The site took it down as soon as I complained. If I hadn’t heard of the site, I wouldn’t have known it was there. One user at that site has posted over 100 videos and I presume all stolen since every one that I looked at was provided by users with different names on youtube. That site has ads on all of the videos.

    Video aggregators take you out of the youtube experience and put you in their site without having to host any videos. Why would youtube allow it? I don’t see that they receive any benefit in it and basically youtube foots the bill for showing and hosting the video on another site. I could understand if when you click the video on an aggregator’s site that a new window opens up and you are back to youtube site.

    Reply

  4. what ever pplllzz give them a break actually i am high a authority at youtube and we make millions! soo it doesnt harm us ! go on and write ur silly essays how youtube will fail..=/. we have been here for 15 almost years

    Reply

  5. wants to how to hair cuts

    Reply

  6. YA SALAM MALADI YAHDOT AMAMNA

    Reply

Leave a Comment of Your Own

Current day month ye@r *